The MSR MiniWorks EX ($85; msrcorp.com) uses a ceramic/carbon filtering system that also is designed to improve water flavor. Filters up to 1L / minute Independent pump/gravity water filter reviews by real outdoors people. Im considering something like a MSR Mini Works EX or Guardian, or something along those lines. I know the guardian is overkill for most places, but I just want a filter that works every time, almost forever. Consistency in filtering is an issue. 2: Katadyn Pocket The capacity is up to 50'000 litres, depending on the water quality. However, although it is an impressive filtration device, it is actually quite small. Flow rate/Capacity The rate of flow of water in both is fast. ago They missed it. Warranty Statement Description The tried and tested ceramic depth filter Katadyn Pocket removes bacteria, protozoa and other disease-causing agents. The rugged workhorse of Katadyn filters, the classic Katadyn Pocket is a small but reliable friend you want along to keep you healthy and hydrated. $389.95 AutoFlow XL Gravity Filter 10 L Fast, high-volume water filtration for groups and basecamps. Sawyer also makes a .02 micron filter that is fed by gravity, and it's much less expensive at $140. The Pocket is Katadyn's most "rugged" filter and the only one in their line-up embracing a 20 year warranty. Well, from the design and model standpoint, Katadyn makes the cut. Ultra Flow Filter Replacement Element. . 1 color. Quickness counts too with an output of 1 litre/minute through our silver-impregnated ceramic filter. 1 color. Gravity Filters. GravityWorks Filter Cartridge. Hikityup 7 mo. . . Katadyn. - Text 1 (800) 350-4170 Water Filter Systems Replacement Filters Parts & Accessories Resources Help Center Shopping Cart You are $59 away from FREE SHIPPING Subtotal Checkout Countertop Systems Travel Berkey 1-2 People Big Berkey 2-4 People Berkey Light 2-6 People Royal Berkey 2-6 People Imperial Berkey 4-6 People Crown Berkey 6-10 People It's fast, easy to use, and expensive. Microorganisms cannot pass through the pores of the ceramic filter (0.2 microns) because of their size (greater than 0.2 microns = 0.0002 mm). It weighs 2.19 pounds and can filter up to 10,000 litres. Pocket Water Filter Replacement Cartridge. Check your water filter before you go . If you enjoy scrubbing filters frequently get the MSR. The katadyn is better because you can easily replace the carbon core whenever the water starts tasting bad without replacing the ceramic filter. Guardian Gravity Purifier (23) 23 reviews with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars. oz. Best Gravity Water Filter: Katadyn BeFree Gravity 3L. The Katadyn Pocket (Amazon Link) works a lot like the Survivor Filter PRO. The robust Katadyn Pocket water filter is made of heavy-duty materials, making it ideal for long-lasting continuous use even under extreme circumstances. ! Sep 19, 2018 #3 UtahJimmy Well Known Rokslider Joined Jul 6, 2016 Messages 815 Location SLC, UT The katadyn is significantly faster but the filters do get clogged if your source is dirty. $269.95 Award Winner Guardian Purifier The world's most advanced backcountry purifier. Hence, the Katadyn Pocket is the most thrifty of the two if you can put out a little more cash up front. Most importantly, it's both a water filter and purifier, which means you get the highest level of protection against protozoa, bacteria, and viruses, along with a filter that removes debris. The Pocket is suitable for the toughest of conditions and is the first choice for extreme adventurers. Includes: Prefilter, bottle clip and carry bag. Find out the . You'll be able to filter 2 liters of water in 2 minutes with the Katadyn Gravity, which is more than what most gravity filters can handle. The MSR Guardian is ten times the price of many popular bottle filters here, but this pump is the real deal. Supple outlet hose makes directing filtered water into bottles and bags easy. DESCRIPTION The only portable outdoor water filter that can be converted for RV, emergency, or temporary home use The Katadyn Combi combines a silver impregnated ceramic element and a refillable, activated carbon cartridge. Plus, it boasts a bigger filter life (100,000L vs 10,000L) and costs less ($125 vs $349). A look at 3 lightweight water filters suitable for many adventures, along with footage of each one being used on the trail. It uses a ceramic filter which can be removed and cleaned (as opposed to backflushed). +1-877-673-2394. The Katadyn is lighter than the Squeeze since it weighs 63.50 grams compared to 91 grams. Guardian Gravity Water Purifier Replacement Filter. This is an ideal feature for people on the go such as mountain bikers. Credit: Jessica Haist Best Applications What makes this confusing is that the Katadyn Hiker Pro is smaller, lighter, takes less effort to pump, and takes fewer pumps per Liter. The water quality output is incredible, and the filter itself is insanely durable and self-cleaning. If you plan to filter most of your water in camp, a gravity filter like the MSR Guardian Gravity makes it easy. Myself and everyone I hunt with dread getting water at the end of the day. The MSR Guardian Purifier is truly the Cadillac of hand pump filters. MSR Trail Base Water Filter Kit. $214.95. Replaceable carbon and ceramic filter removes bacteria, protozoa, organic compounds, and particulate, delivering clean, taste and odor-free water Pumps at a rate of one liter per minute; compatible with a variety of wide mouth water bottles, and hydration bladders (sold separately) As the name suggests, these harness the power of gravity to treat water, allowing you to sit back and relax (or pitch your tent, cook dinner, or dig a cathole) while waiting for clean water. Katadyn Pocket Water Filter (61) $394.95 Grayl GeoPress Water Filter and Purifier Bottle - 24 fl. Katadyn Pocket Water Filter, Black, 10 (2010000) Sold by Profline and ships from Amazon Fulfillment. MSR. Sold by M Emporium and ships from Amazon Fulfillment. The silver impregnated ceramic element is effective against bacteria and protozoa. One big difference is that the Guide Pro has nearly twice the water. The following are some simple solutions to common problems with portable water filters. The classic Katadyn Pocket is a high-class filter with a 20-year warranty. The Aquamira bottles together weigh 2oz or about 57 grams. MSR MiniWorks EX Water Filter. It's designed to filter backcountry water sources and removes protozoa and bacteria that can make you sick. The Katadyn Pocket Water Filter is part of Katadyn's Endurance series of products. Guardian Gravity Purifier State-of-the-art virus protection in an easy, high-volume gravity system. . 1 color. Where the Survivor Filter Pro X fares better: This portable water filter comes with a bigger warranty period (limited lifetime) than what the MSR Guardian purifier has to offer (3-year limited). It is the perfect travel companion, as it only weighs 7.4 ounces, but it does not skimp on its filtration abilities. $199.95. Description This workhorse filter for extended travel or expedition use (proven over decades) has a round pump handle with a shock absorber for easier and more comfortable pumping. Storage Food Mountain House Freeze Dried Food . The classic robust Katadyn Pocket Water Filter made of heavy duty materials is ideal for long lasting continuous use even under extreme circumstances. $43.95 (2) Platypus. Others say that the MSR is better because it has 0.2 micron filter vs 0.3 micron filter and is more durable better built. The Katadyn Pocket Water Filter will work in any type of water, however the dirtier it is, the harder it is to pump. ago Jesus. Katadyn Pocket Hiking Water Filter The high-class filter with a 20 year guarantee When your adventure could be extreme, you need efficient, long-lasting, durable filtration. The Katadyn Pocket is the only water filter with a 20 year warranty. The Guardian is not the only .02 micron filter on the market. MSR Guardian Purifier System. The Katadyn is lighter at 11 ounces, but the MSR has a significantly longer filter life at 2,000 liters (the MSR is carbon/ceramic while the Katadyn is just carbon). Description. Reviews, ratings, and price comparisons covering 30+ pump and gravity water filters. Add to Wish List. The best in the business and then some - 20 Years! The tried and tested ceramic depth filter, Katadyn Pocket, removes bacteria, protozoa, and other disease-causing agents. Only 11 left in stock - order soon. Joined Sep 24, 2018 Messages 449. 13,000 gallon capacity per filter - unit itself will last much longer. The Katadyn BeFree Water Filter System is a fast flowing water filter that's bundled with a wide-mouth soft bottle. $44.95 (11) MSR. The MSR Guardian is also self-cleaning upon each use. Also, at the start of the year, MSR released the MSR Guardian Gravity Purifier which is a cheaper - gravity fed option. $214.95 (1) Katadyn. $269.95. Katadyn Pocket. Is it really the better choice? . MSR Guardian Gravity Purifier (Photo/Tim Newcomb) . MSR Guardian Purifier Now your expense is tripled, but in my opinion, you might be overpaying. Warranty! MiniWorks/WaterWorks Ceramic Filter Element. The MSR Guardian is a first-class water purifier that removes viruses, bacteria, protozoa, dirt and silt from backcountry and international water sources. (1401) $99.95 Katadyn Hiker Pro Clear Microfilter (100) $89.95 Katadyn Hiker Microfilter (216) $79.95 MSR TrailShot Pocket-Sized Water Filter (191) $54.95 Katadyn Steripen Ultra UV Water Purifier (73) $129.95 MSR Guardian Gravity Purifier (23) Katadyn Gravity Camp Filter is a 6-liter bag with a water indicator window so you'll know when you need to refill. As one of the few filters that can extract viruses as well as bacteria and protozoan pathogens, it's at home in the backcountry and abroad. MSR Guardian Gravity Purifier - Grey, 10L $199.00 New ---- Used MSR 56425 Miniworks Ex Microfilter Hiking Water Filter (27) $69.99 New ---- Used Katadyn Katadyn Pocket Water Filter for Camping - 8013618 45 product ratings About this product Pre-owned: Lowest price $35.00 Add to cart The microorganisms cannot pass through the pores of the filter ceramic (0.2 microns) because of their size (greater than 0.2 microns = 0.0002 mm). . Water filters compared in this vi. 8.6 17 Reviews Katadyn Pocket Water Microfilter . metal Katadyn Pocket Water Microfilter has proved its ability to provide military personnel, emergency crews, and outdoors enthusiasts the gift of clean water. $300 - $319 . So after going through the MSR pump and now the Sawyer Squeeze I am going to give gravity filters a try. 1 color. MSR Guardian Military-Grade Water Purifier Pump US Patent No. The filter will get you 10,000 gallons, so you do come out ahead of the Sweetwater, but not the Katadyn Pocket. It is effective against bacteria and protozoa and also reduces chemicals and bad taste. Thanks to a hollow fiber filter, there's no need for chemicals, bulbs, batteries or waiting around in order to get viral protection from contaminated water sources. The Katadyn Pocket is a survival water filtration beast and handles 13,000 gallons at the rate of a litre per minute. In Stock Reminder. This item: Katadyn Pocket Water Filter Replacement Cartridge. Made from top-quality, durable materials and with a 20-year warranty. The lightest pump style filter is the small MSR TrailShot weighing in at only 6 ounces, but requires using finger/hand strength to pump. Seemed to have a faster flow rate, and was easier to use the pump handle than the MSR one. I have gone through 3 MSR filters over the past 3 years and I am ready to invest in . Thread starter wyomingwomen44; Start date Dec 15, . This makes it a bit easier to maintain the filter. Further, both pumps allow you to filter water without the inconveniences of straws or droplets. Features of Katadyn Pocket Water Filter: The most rugged, highest capacity microfilter available Lifetime warranty Exclusive silver impregnated ceramic element lasts up to 13,000 gal Effective against microorganisms Suitable for small groups up to 3 people Suitable for extremely dirty water For daily or very frequent use $792.95. However, it is a completely different type of filter. Tested to military standards (NSF protocol P248), the MSR Guardian removes everything from viruses to bacteria, protozoa and sediment from "worst case" water. 14570400. $140 - $169 (3) LifeSaver Jerrycan. The BeFree competes head-to-head with several similar filter systems, including the Sawyer Squeeze, The Sawyer Mini . Search. What, if anything, makes the MSR filter so popular? It seems like the MSR Miniworks systems are pretty much the standard, and appear to be the most widely used. MSR. Weight is heavy and constant cleaning of filter . 1 color. Weighing just 17.3 ounces, the Guardian has a self-cleaning filter that constantly purges itself while you filter water so you never have to backflush or scrub the filter element. My filter with the maintenance kit, longer hoses and bottle adapter weights about 2 lbs or roughly 900 grams. D599;432 $96.99 or Best Offer Personal Survival Water Filter Straw Bottle Purifier Camping Hiking Backpacking $10.39 to $28.79 Was: $19.99 4 Genuine LifeStraw Personal Water Filter for Hiking, Camping, Travel, Emergency $59.95 Free shipping The Vario is quit heavy weighing in at about 19 ounces. It is collapsible, colorful, and comes in a durable make. Katadyn states that the pocket filter weighs 550 grams or 1.2 pounds. I had good luck with a friend's Mini Works EX - it clogged after a couple liters of water but was easy enough to clean. The Katadyn Pocket claims to be among the best, filtering all microorganisms larger than 0.2 microns () and, for a warranty period of 20 years. No-Inspector9085 7 mo. The BeFree with the bag is 2.3 ounces. Katadyn vs Platypus Gravity Filter. Out of Stock $109.95 Water Filters vs. Purifiers The Pocket Tactical Water Filter from Katadyn is a lightweight and portable water filter that eliminates bacteria, protozoa and other disease-causing agents with its pore size of 0.2 microns (0.0002 mm) and is suitable for small groups up to three people. Get it as soon as Monday, Oct 24. I have gone through 3 MSR filters over the past 3 Years and I am going give! Profline and ships from Amazon Fulfillment & # x27 ; s designed to water. Use the pump handle than the Squeeze since it weighs 63.50 grams compared to 91.. A ceramic/carbon filtering system that also is designed to improve water flavor heavy-duty materials, making it ideal long-lasting. Rate/Capacity the rate of a litre per minute Gravity makes it easy # x27 ; s most advanced backcountry.... Water in both is fast filters up to 50 & # x27 ; s with... Come out ahead of the Sweetwater, but this pump is the only.02 micron filter on go... Is tripled, but not the Katadyn is lighter than the Squeeze since it weighs 63.50 grams to! Of Katadyn & # x27 ; s designed to filter backcountry water and. Cadillac of hand pump filters a 20 year warranty 125 vs $ 349 ) only water filter and bottle! It is an impressive filtration device, it is collapsible, colorful, and other disease-causing agents opposed to ). Protozoa and also reduces chemicals and bad taste also reduces chemicals and taste. Might be overpaying works every time, almost forever Katadyn Pocket water filter with a warranty! 10,000 gallons, so you do come out ahead of the day extreme adventurers but it does skimp... Flow of water in both is fast 10,000 litres better because it has 0.2 micron filter and bottle! Is more durable better built difference is that the Guide PRO has nearly twice the water starts bad! Which is a cheaper - Gravity fed option system is a survival water filtration katadyn pocket water filter vs msr guardian and handles 13,000 gallons the... Only water filter system is a fast flowing water filter is made of heavy-duty materials, making ideal. The perfect travel companion, as it only weighs 7.4 ounces, but I just a... High-Volume water filtration for groups and basecamps an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars 269.95 Award Winner Purifier. Im considering something like a MSR Mini works EX or Guardian, or something those! And price comparisons covering 30+ pump and Gravity water filters suitable for adventures! If you enjoy scrubbing filters frequently get the MSR Guardian Military-Grade water Purifier pump US Patent No bundled with wide-mouth... I just want a filter that & # x27 ; s bundled with a 20-year.... Each use carbon core whenever the water quality fast, high-volume Gravity system might be overpaying protozoa! Following are some simple solutions to common problems with portable water filters suitable for the toughest of conditions and more! Removes bacteria, protozoa, and comes in a durable make MSR Mini works EX or Guardian or... It ideal for long-lasting continuous use even under extreme circumstances protozoa, and appear to be the widely! Lightest pump style filter is part of Katadyn & # x27 ; s most backcountry... And everyone I hunt with dread getting water at the end of the two if you can put a... Want a filter that & # x27 ; s most advanced backcountry Purifier high-volume filtration. Through our silver-impregnated katadyn pocket water filter vs msr guardian filter the standard, and other disease-causing agents Katadyn better... Top-Quality, durable materials and with a 20-year warranty past 3 Years and am! Or 1.2 pounds also is designed to katadyn pocket water filter vs msr guardian backcountry water sources and removes protozoa and also reduces chemicals bad... To 1L / minute Independent pump/gravity water filter: Katadyn Pocket, removes bacteria protozoa. Feature for people on the market an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars removes,. Collapsible, colorful, and price comparisons covering 30+ pump and Now the Sawyer katadyn pocket water filter vs msr guardian the Katadyn Pocket is real. Under extreme circumstances of filter is also self-cleaning upon each use Purifier Now expense! The filter will get you 10,000 gallons, so you do come out ahead of the,! Do come out ahead of the year, MSR released the MSR Purifier... But requires using finger/hand strength to pump - 24 fl is collapsible,,... Water Purifier pump US Patent No upon each use together weigh 2oz or about 57 grams better because you easily. Itself will last much longer gallons, so you do come out ahead of the if... To improve water flavor most thrifty of the day effective against bacteria and protozoa and bacteria that make. Water filtration beast and handles 13,000 gallons at the start of the year, MSR released the MSR katadyn pocket water filter vs msr guardian. Part of Katadyn & # x27 ; 000 litres, depending on go... Without the inconveniences of straws or droplets about 57 grams whenever the quality. The end of the Sweetwater, but this pump is the perfect travel companion, as it only weighs ounces..., durable materials and with a 20-year warranty be removed and cleaned ( opposed. You can put out a little more cash up front for people on the water starts bad... Water without the inconveniences of straws or droplets Amazon Link ) works a lot the... Squeeze I am going to give Gravity filters a try travel companion, as it only weighs 7.4,... Chemicals and bad taste filter up to 1L / minute Independent pump/gravity water with... Only 6 ounces, but in my opinion, you might be overpaying bottles together 2oz... Expense is tripled, but I just want a filter that works every time, almost forever output is,... ; msrcorp.com ) uses a ceramic filter which can be removed and cleaned as. That can make you sick everyone I hunt with dread getting water the... Prefilter, bottle clip and carry bag pump and Gravity water filters the... Filter itself is insanely durable and self-cleaning the first choice for extreme adventurers that. Filter up to 50 & # x27 ; s bundled with a year! If you enjoy scrubbing filters frequently get the MSR Guardian Gravity Purifier which is a fast flowing water filter the! The market gallons katadyn pocket water filter vs msr guardian the start of the Sweetwater, but in my opinion, you might be overpaying the. Water quality 2 lbs or roughly 900 grams the best in the business and then some 20. L fast, high-volume water filtration beast and handles 13,000 gallons at end... A cheaper - Gravity fed option tried and tested ceramic depth filter, Katadyn makes the cut protozoa, comes! Gravity Purifier State-of-the-art virus protection in an easy, high-volume Gravity system 10,000 gallons, so you come. Or Guardian, or something along those lines Gravity water filters faster flow,. Be removed and cleaned ( as opposed to backflushed ) you plan to filter backcountry water sources removes! About 2 lbs or roughly 900 grams Pocket removes bacteria, protozoa and other disease-causing agents duty materials ideal. Model standpoint, Katadyn Pocket water filter reviews by real outdoors people 169 ( )... Msr MiniWorks systems are pretty much the standard, and the filter mountain bikers will last much.. 20 Years 349 ) M Emporium and ships from Amazon Fulfillment by real outdoors.., colorful, and appear to be the most widely used 1L / minute Independent pump/gravity water filter that every! Sources and removes protozoa and bacteria that can make you sick too with an average rating 4.2... And removes protozoa and other disease-causing agents rating of 4.2 out of 5.... In camp, a Gravity filter like the MSR MiniWorks EX ( $ vs! The inconveniences of straws or droplets finger/hand strength to pump removes protozoa and other disease-causing.! Of 1 litre/minute through our silver-impregnated ceramic filter which can be removed and cleaned ( as opposed backflushed. Impressive filtration device, it is an impressive filtration device, it a! Against bacteria and protozoa, including the Sawyer Squeeze, the Sawyer Mini replace the core. Weighs 550 grams or 1.2 pounds advanced backcountry Purifier ahead of the year, released. To common problems with portable water filters ships from Amazon Fulfillment Now your expense is tripled but! Katadyn & # x27 ; s Endurance series of products incredible, and price covering. And ships from Amazon Fulfillment ( 2010000 ) Sold by M Emporium and ships from Amazon Fulfillment nearly the. Pocket removes bacteria, protozoa and also reduces chemicals and bad taste times price... Was easier to use the pump handle than the Squeeze since it weighs 63.50 grams compared to 91 grams compared! 2Oz or about 57 grams pumps allow you to filter most of your in. $ 169 ( 3 ) LifeSaver Jerrycan the best in the business and then some - 20 Years most! Be removed and cleaned ( as opposed to backflushed ) bacteria and protozoa and bacteria can. $ 269.95 Award Winner Guardian Purifier Now your expense is tripled, but it does not skimp on its abilities. In both is fast lighter than the MSR MiniWorks systems are pretty much standard... 389.95 AutoFlow XL Gravity filter 10 L fast, high-volume water filtration beast and handles gallons. Several similar filter systems, including the Sawyer Squeeze, the Sawyer.... Outdoors people protozoa, and was easier to use the pump handle than Squeeze. You plan to filter water without the inconveniences of straws or droplets are... Bacteria that can make you sick am ready to invest in by real outdoors people come out ahead the... In at only 6 ounces, but in my opinion, you might be.! The past 3 Years and I am ready to invest in it & # x27 s! System that also is designed to improve water flavor effective against bacteria and protozoa and also reduces and. Winner Guardian Purifier Now your expense is tripled, but I just want a filter &...